Forums › General Discussion › Nav Lights

Viewing 22 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #67820
      Anonymous

      While the mast is down and I am rewiering am now contemplating masthead navigation tri-color and anchor light. I was thinking about the new HELLA NaviLED tri color / anchor combo. In speaking with my marina manager about mast head vs deck level he had an intereting commnet – we said Captain Tom – if the nav light go out aloft then you have to go aloft to fix / figure out why.
      Any opinions welcome…….

      Eric
      NAVASANA

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74456
      RichCarter
      Participant

      If your masthead lights go out you still have your deck lights. I have a 12v relay setup. It is energized by the ignition key. When I turn the engine on it switches the nav lights over from masthead to deck to keep me legal. There’s a three position switch for each set. The three positions are: On, Off, auto. Both are normally left in “auto”. The whole thing is powered through the nav-light circuit-breaker. To turn on the nav-lights I turn on the breaker. I can bypass the relay and either force each set of lights on or off.

      I also have a similar switch for the engine blower.

      I’ve considered putting a photo-detector switch in to automate the anchor light. It would switch on at dusk and off at dawn.

      Regards
      Rich


      Original Message


      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74457
      madsailor
      Moderator

      Hi Eric,

      Basically you should have both – sailing out in the ocean or large waters (Great Lakes) during dark the masthead light is more visible to large ships and farther away due to height.

      When you are motoring at night, it is an illegal lighting arrangement to have the steaming light below the running lights – so you have to use the down low nav lights plus the steaming light.

      If you are in narrow waters, such as the ICW or even in sounds like the Long Island Sound, people will look low on the water for boats so the lower ones are better. 

      I will say this:  if you are depending on the original lights in the hull as your navigation lights, you are not very visible.  I took all mine out and plugged the holes.  I installed a single nav light on the bow pulpit and a stern light on the stern pulpit.  I replace all my nav lighting bulbs with Dr. Led either dual color, tricolor, or white bulbs to fit the light.  With LEDs you can't use a white light with a red lens.  It won't work.  Anyway, the nav light draw now is about .2 amp as opposed to the original 2.5 amp.

      Bob

      —
      Bob Fine
      s/v Pelican
      Pearson 424 Hull #8
      http://thesailinglife.blogspot.com
      Follow me at: http://www.tinyurl.com/WhereIsBobFine

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74458
      Hull152_Patrick
      Spectator

      I bought an OGM LED with Strobe and Photdiode it is not installed yet and the masts are still laying in their cradles in the yard.
      https://secure.orcagreen.com/xcart/product.php?productid=16134&cat=249&page=1

      I do not plan on removing my deck level lights though, just didn’t seem worth it to me, although they look like crap so maybe some day I’ll care enough to replace them, but it’s not a priority.

      -p

      —-
      s/v Deep Playa | Pearson 424 Hull #152 | http://www.DeepPlaya.com

      From:
      Sent: Monday, November 30, 2009 9:54 AM
      To:
      Subject: Re: Nav Lights

      p { margin: 0; }
      If your masthead lights go out you still have your deck lights. I have a 12v relay setup. It is energized by the ignition key. When I turn the engine on it switches the nav lights over from masthead to deck to keep me legal. There’s a three position switch for each set. The three positions are: On, Off, auto. Both are normally left in “auto”. The whole thing is powered through the nav-light circuit-breaker. To turn on the nav-lights I turn on the breaker. I can bypass the relay and either force each set of lights on or off.

      I also have a similar switch for the engine blower.

      I’ve considered putting a photo-detector switch in to automate the anchor light. It would switch on at dusk and off at dawn.

      Regards
      Rich


      Original Message


      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

      Owners no more...
      Thanks Dawn and Patrick!

    • #74459
      madsailor
      Moderator

      Which array is that?  How much was it, and how many watts and where did you get it?

      Bob

      On Mon, Nov 30, 2009 at 1:26 PM, Thatcher A. Stone < ([email][/email])> wrote:

      Quote:
      I have the Hella Nav LED’s installed on the rail as recently highlighted in either a SAIL or CRUISING WORLD article. Slowly I have replaced all my lights aboard to LED or mostly LED. When I say mostly I mean some of the multiple cabin lights are still incandescent.
       
      At the same time I put in a large photovoltaic panel for electricity. Just forward of the main companionway.
       
      Very pleased with the results: I am able to run the nav lights in the PM and by 11 AM the drain is charged.
       
      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74460
      john stevenson
      Participant

      +1 to Bob's comments about having both masthead and deck level lights.  Those Perko bow lights Pearson installed in the hull will eventually need to be replaced.  I replaced mine 3 years ago with an Aqua Signal dual light fixture on the bow rail and sealed the holes for the old lights with a thin sheet of Lexan (it was what I had).  I was amazed that the original lights lasted as long as they did.  They were not sealed from the elements.  I guess the PO never did any hard sailing.
      I replaced my masthead lights with DrLEDs last year.  The previous incandescent bulbs drew around 2A.  I don't know what the LEDs draw.  The masthead anchor light is very dim, but visible.  I learned from one winter anchoring in the Bahamas it is better to have the anchor light near deck level.  The guys zooming around the harbor at night in their big RIBs or center console fishing boats are not looking up, if they're looking at all.  So my anchor light now is an LED cluster from Bebi Electronics  hung on the end of the boom.  In spite of the fact Bebi is located in Fiji, their prices and shipping costs are very competitive.
      I left the deck level lights with incandescent bulbs as they are normally only on when motoring.

      On Mon, Nov 30, 2009 at 2:17 PM, Robert Fine < ([email][/email])> wrote:

      Quote:
      Which array is that?  How much was it, and how many watts and where did you get it?

      Bob

      On Mon, Nov 30, 2009 at 1:26 PM, Thatcher A. Stone < ([email][/email])> wrote:

      Quote:
      I have the Hella Nav LED’s installed on the rail as recently highlighted in either a SAIL or CRUISING WORLD article. Slowly I have replaced all my lights aboard to LED or mostly LED. When I say mostly I mean some of the multiple cabin lights are still incandescent.
       
      At the same time I put in a large photovoltaic panel for electricity. Just forward of the main companionway.
       
      Very pleased with the results: I am able to run the nav lights in the PM and by 11 AM the drain is charged.
       
      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74461
      Anonymous

      I don’t know what you mean by array. It’s a Sunsei purchased on line from the manufacturer in Montreal. Comes with wiring, installation, and a charging light panel.

      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74462
      RichCarter
      Participant

      “it is better to have the anchor light near deck level. “

      I can second that having almost been hit one night by a powerboat. He screamed “PUT OUT AN ANCHOR LIGHT” as he zipped past at about 30kts. He never apparently looked up.

      Putting a light on deck is a problem too. There are few places where it can be hung without leaving a blind spot. I find that hanging it from the backstay above the boom works best for me. I don’t have a mizzen. Maybe one on each side hanging from the shrouds would work too, but that’s twice the power drain. Then there’s where to plug it in. I’ve resorted to a not legal battery-powered lantern from the backstay and the legal masthead.

      Rich


      Original Message


      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74464
      madsailor
      Moderator

      Hi Thatcher,
       
      That's what I wanted to know – it's a Sunsei photovoltaic array, but what size? In watts? 
       
      Thanks!
       
      Bob

      On Mon, Nov 30, 2009 at 3:25 PM, Thatcher A. Stone < ([email][/email])> wrote:

      Quote:
      I don’t know what you mean by array. It’s a Sunsei  purchased on line from the manufacturer in Montreal. Comes with wiring, installation, and a charging light panel.
       
      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74466
      Anonymous

      Well, what he said is true, however, you still need a light at the masthead to be LEGAL at anchor. You can;t run the tricolor when motoring anyhow…

      I have a Orca Green Tri-color/anchor/strobe and can’t say enough good things about it. I grumbled at the price when I bought it, but I’m sure glad I did. It is ALWAYS the brightest light in the marina which makes it easy for a dim bulb like me to find my way home 🙂

      I still have ‘traditional” running lights. I figure when the engine is on I can afford the extra power, when sailing I want LED.

      If the Led goes out I’ll turn on the regular nav lights &/or motor.

      On 11/30/09 8:57 AM, “Eric Lorentzon” <> wrote:

      While the mast is down and I am rewiering am now contemplating masthead navigation tri-color and anchor light. I was thinking about the new HELLA NaviLED tri color / anchor combo. In speaking with my marina manager about mast head vs deck level he had an intereting commnet – we said Captain Tom – if the nav light go out aloft then you have to go aloft to fix / figure out why.
      Any opinions welcome…….

      Eric
      NAVASANA

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74467
      petedd
      Participant

      Coming in at night at Sapelo Island, Ga I almost ran down a fool who was
      anchored in the dead center of the channel with an anchor light, are you
      ready for this… on the front of his mast. (the current was running
      out lightly, so he was bow upstream). Saw the dot on the radar that
      was his boat and steered around him.

      Anchor lights need to be “all around”. I don’t imagine there is any
      harm in hanging more than one light if they are low.

      Pete

      wrote:

      Quote:
      “it is better to have the anchor light near deck level. “

      I can second that having almost been hit one night by a powerboat. He
      screamed “PUT OUT AN ANCHOR LIGHT” as he zipped past at about 30kts.
      He never apparently looked up.

      Putting a light on deck is a problem too. There are few places where
      it can be hung without leaving a blind spot. I find that hanging it
      from the backstay above the boom works best for me. I don’t have a
      mizzen. Maybe one on each side hanging from the shrouds would work
      too, but that’s twice the power drain. Then there’s where to plug it
      in. I’ve resorted to a not legal battery-powered lantern from the
      backstay and the legal masthead.

      Rich


      Original Message


      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74468
      Anonymous

      Don’t have that data handy. Go to their website, it’s the 1200 watt item I believe.

      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74469
      Anonymous

      I hang a solar powered light just above my davit system. It comes on at night automatically, uses no energy, and I don’t have to remember to turnit on and off..real cheap and yet quite bright. Might be confusing when I do a night passage so I turn it off then.

      Joe,

      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74470
      Anonymous

      All great information, thanks. I am going to put up a masthead tri color LED and keep the original running lights for motoring. May someday upgrade those too…..But as you all know the list only grows!
      Eric

      — On Tue, 12/1/09, Joseph Steiner <> wrote:

      Quote:
      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74471
      Anonymous

      But before I go I can’t resist adding this. I installed an LED Aqua Signal masthead tri-color + anchor light. Sealed the old hull running lights and mounted a single port/starboard light beneath an athwartships board just inboard of the forward end of the bow pulpit. I put my new “deck level” stern light on the mizzen masthead, rather than on the stern rail. In my experience, the typical rail-mounted stern light often creates a giant blind spot by reflecting and refracting off the mist and exhaust just astern of the boat underway, especially when motoring. As a result, the watch keeper cannot see astern, which is not a good thing.

      Regarding deck level anchor light blind spots, I hang one Home Depot garden-variety solar lamp at the end of the mizzen boom, and another one from the two genoa sheets pulled together above the foredeck. At least one of the lights is visible from every angle of approach, and the pair make my boat easy for me to find at night in a crowded harbor.

      Have fun!

      Tor
      ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
      Silver Heels, P-424 #17
      http://www.SilverHeels.us
      ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

      Quote:

      Original Message


      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74474
      petedd
      Participant

      Tor,

      Check the COLREGS. I am pretty sure that there is a height limit and
      requirement regarding proximity to the transom for the stern light.

      Pete

      Silver Heels wrote:

      Quote:
      *But before I go I can’t resist adding this. I installed an LED Aqua
      Signal masthead tri-color + anchor light. Sealed the old hull running
      lights and mounted a single port/starboard light beneath an
      athwartships board just inboard of the forward end of the bow
      pulpit. I put my new “deck level” stern light _on the mizzen
      masthead_, rather than on the stern rail. In my experience, the
      typical rail-mounted stern light often creates a giant blind spot by
      reflecting and refracting off the mist and exhaust just astern of the
      boat underway, especially when motoring. As a result, the watch keeper
      cannot see astern, which is not a good thing. *
      **
      *Regarding deck level anchor light blind spots, I hang one Home Depot
      garden-variety solar lamp at the end of the mizzen boom, and another
      one from the two genoa sheets pulled together above the foredeck. At
      least one of the lights is visible from every angle of approach, and
      the pair make my boat easy for me to find at night in a crowded harbor. *
      **
      *Have fun!*
      **
      *Tor
      ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
      Silver Heels, P-424 #17
      http://www.SilverHeels.us
      ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*


      Original Message


      *<.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74475
      john stevenson
      Participant

      Pete,
      I just did a quick check on the USCG site and I can find no specification for the height of the stern light.  The only position requirement is that it be as close to the stern as practical.  Since Tor does not believe the light on the stern rail is practical because of the glare it provides to the helmsperson, it would seem his choice of location conforms.  Of course it should conform to the requirement for a visible arc of 135 deg, which the original stern light installed by Pearson on the transom does not.
      I've considered using bow and stern anchor lights as Tor does, but I am concerned the idiots driving through the anchorage at night might think it was two boats and decide to go between them.

      On Tue, Dec 1, 2009 at 7:49 PM, Pete Dubler < ([email][/email])> wrote:

      Quote:
      Tor,

      Check the COLREGS.  I am pretty sure that there is a height limit and requirement regarding proximity to the transom for the stern light.

      Pete

      Silver Heels wrote:

      Quote:
      *But before I go I can't resist adding this. I installed an LED Aqua Signal masthead tri-color + anchor light. Sealed the old hull running lights and mounted a single port/starboard light beneath an athwartships board just inboard of the forward end of the bow pulpit. I put my new “deck level” stern light _on the mizzen masthead_, rather than on the stern rail. In my experience, the typical rail-mounted stern light often creates a giant blind spot by reflecting and refracting off the mist and exhaust just astern of the boat underway, especially when motoring. As a result, the watch keeper cannot see astern, which is not a good thing. *

      ** *Regarding deck level anchor light blind spots, I hang one Home Depot garden-variety solar lamp at the end of the mizzen boom, and another one from the two genoa sheets pulled together above the foredeck. At least one of the lights is visible from every angle of approach, and the pair make my boat easy for me to find at night in a crowded harbor. *
      ** *Have fun!*
      ** *Tor
      ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
      Silver Heels, P-424 #17
      http://www.SilverHeels.us
      ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*

         


      Original Message


         *<.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74476
      petedd
      Participant

      John,

      I happily stand corrected. (I had some memory or researching this once
      as we were designing a bow and stern light set, but I guess I was mistaken).
      The height, precise color, beam dispersion, etc are not covered in the
      Colregs themselves but rather in ANNEX 1:
      http://www.navcen.uscg.gov/mwv/navrules/annexes/annex_1Intl.htm

      I had to LOL when you mentioned someone trying to go between split
      anchor lights…

      Pete

      John Stevenson wrote:

      Quote:
      Pete,
      I just did a quick check on the USCG site and I can find no
      specification for the height of the stern light. The only position
      requirement is that it be as close to the stern as practical. Since
      Tor does not believe the light on the stern rail is practical because
      of the glare it provides to the helmsperson, it would seem his choice
      of location conforms. Of course it should conform to the requirement
      for a visible arc of 135 deg, which the original stern light installed
      by Pearson on the transom does not.
      I’ve considered using bow and stern anchor lights as Tor does, but I
      am concerned the idiots driving through the anchorage at night might
      think it was two boats and decide to go between them.

      On Tue, Dec 1, 2009 at 7:49 PM, Pete Dubler <
      > wrote:

      Tor,

      Check the COLREGS. I am pretty sure that there is a height limit
      and requirement regarding proximity to the transom for the stern
      light.

      Pete

      Silver Heels wrote:

      *But before I go I can’t resist adding this. I installed an
      LED Aqua Signal masthead tri-color + anchor light. Sealed the
      old hull running lights and mounted a single port/starboard
      light beneath an athwartships board just inboard of the
      forward end of the bow pulpit. I put my new “deck level” stern
      light _on the mizzen masthead_, rather than on the stern rail.
      In my experience, the typical rail-mounted stern light often
      creates a giant blind spot by reflecting and refracting off
      the mist and exhaust just astern of the boat underway,
      especially when motoring. As a result, the watch keeper cannot
      see astern, which is not a good thing. *

      ** *Regarding deck level anchor light blind spots, I hang one
      Home Depot garden-variety solar lamp at the end of the mizzen
      boom, and another one from the two genoa sheets pulled
      together above the foredeck. At least one of the lights is
      visible from every angle of approach, and the pair make my
      boat easy for me to find at night in a crowded harbor. *
      ** *Have fun!*
      ** *Tor
      ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
      Silver Heels, P-424 #17
      http://www.SilverHeels.us <http://www.SilverHeels.us>
      ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*


      Original Message


      *<.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74477
      Anonymous

      That would be a steaming light not an anchor light 🙂

      Having a bunch of lights on down low won’t save you either, google ‘bismark
      Dinius’

      On 11/30/09 7:37 PM, “Pete Dubler” <> wrote:

      Quote:
      Coming in at night at Sapelo Island, Ga I almost ran down a fool who was
      anchored in the dead center of the channel with an anchor light, are you
      ready for this… on the front of his mast. (the current was running
      out lightly, so he was bow upstream). Saw the dot on the radar that
      was his boat and steered around him.

      Anchor lights need to be “all around”. I don’t imagine there is any
      harm in hanging more than one light if they are low.

      Pete

      wrote:

      Quote:
      “it is better to have the anchor light near deck level. “

      I can second that having almost been hit one night by a powerboat. He
      screamed “PUT OUT AN ANCHOR LIGHT” as he zipped past at about 30kts.
      He never apparently looked up.

      Putting a light on deck is a problem too. There are few places where
      it can be hung without leaving a blind spot. I find that hanging it
      from the backstay above the boom works best for me. I don’t have a
      mizzen. Maybe one on each side hanging from the shrouds would work
      too, but that’s twice the power drain. Then there’s where to plug it
      in. I’ve resorted to a not legal battery-powered lantern from the
      backstay and the legal masthead.

      Rich


      Original Message


      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74478
      madsailor
      Moderator

      An anchor light must be an all around white light and for our boats, I believe visible for three miles (it might be two).  Split lights are not legal anchor lights.  That's why they're typically at the top of a cabin or mast – so a single light can be seen and not confused with anything else.

      Bob

      —
      Bob Fine
      s/v Pelican
      Pearson 424 Hull #8
      http://thesailinglife.blogspot.com
      Follow me at: http://www.tinyurl.com/WhereIsBobFine

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74479
      Hull152_Patrick
      Spectator

      Here’s a handly link for looking up the rules:

      Navigation Rules Online
      http://www.navcen.uscg.gov/mwv/navrules/rotr_online.htm

      -p
      —-
      s/v Deep Playa | Pearson 424 Hull #152 | http://www.DeepPlaya.com

      From: “Robert Fine” <>
      Sent: Wednesday, December 02, 2009 3:59 PM
      To:
      Subject: Re: Nav Lights

      An anchor light must be an all around white light and for our boats, I believe visible for three miles (it might be two). Split lights are not legal anchor lights. That’s why they’re typically at the top of a cabin or mast – so a single light can be seen and not confused with anything else.

      Bob

      —
      Bob Fine
      s/v Pelican
      Pearson 424 Hull #8
      http://thesailinglife.blogspot.com
      Follow me at: http://www.tinyurl.com/WhereIsBobFine

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

      Owners no more...
      Thanks Dawn and Patrick!

    • #74480
      Anonymous

      I concur with 2 miles visibility.

      Norris Larson on Easy Reach, which I’m sad to say has two interested buyers.

      — On Wed, 12/2/09, Robert Fine <> wrote:

      Quote:
      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #74481
      sumocean
      Participant

      I still like my rechargeable patio lights in the rod holders on either side of the cockpit. Being outboard enough to light the side of the hull for boats that don’t look up.

      Linus

      <.. snip>

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

Viewing 22 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.