Forums › General Discussion › FuelTank Leak Part 3

Viewing 8 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #68942
      Anonymous

        I finally got the fuel tank out last Friday.  Pulled the tank out and loaded it in my truck by myself. Yikes…..
         The old tank slipped out pretty easy once I removed the Racor filter that was mounted on the side of the engine compartment. The water muffler also had to be removed along with the coolant hoses that go to the hot water heater. oh, yeah, the two aft motor mounts also had to be removed. Then it slipped right out and up thru the companionway.  The bottom of the tank had a small pin hole leak, with several bubbles in the paint??  epoxy?  that look like they were about to pop thru.

         I pulled the fuel pick up tube out. It is a piece of SS tubing about 6 inches long. Attached to the tube is a rubber fuel hose (epoxied on) with a brass fitting on the end of the hose. The total length is 34 inches. Mind you, the tank is only 23 1/2 inches deep!! I would have thought it should have been like, 23 inches?
         The whole cradle that the tank rests on is infused with diesel. Actually, it’s seeping out of the wood. Some of the plywood strips on the bottom  needs to replaced. They are3/4′ x  6″ wide x 34″ with some kind of beam stiffener attached to the bottom. Hard to tell what kind of wood it is, maybe teak or mahogany? Probably replace with plywood and oak, covered in West epoxy.
          I’ll  have to a try and figure out how to clean up the diesel soaked wood that can’t be replaced – Ideas?

          As I had stated before, one of the reasons I chose this hull from the 3 others I had looked at back in 2003, was that the tank was supposed to have been replaced in 2000. Looking at the sticker attached to the tank thru the gauge viewing port in the cockpit, you can see the sticker, and it looked like it was a “00”. Plus what the PO had stated. After I pulled the tank, it clearly says “80”. So I guess I got screwed.

      More coming soon
      Alan
      UNABATED #140
      _______________________________________________
      maillist mailing list

      https://pearson424.org/mailman/listinfo/maillist_pearson424.org

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #81199
      Anonymous

      The pickup wasn’t original. The reason it was so long was so that it would
      pick up off the bottom of the tank so water wouldn’t sit there. The
      original was a stainless tube silver soldered to the tank top fitting
      straight down to within 1/2″ of the bottom.

      Bob

      On Wed, Jul 2, 2014 at 7:29 AM, Alan via maillist
      wrote:

      I finally got the fuel tank out last Friday. Pulled the tank out and
      loaded it in my truck by myself. Yikes…..
      The old tank slipped out pretty easy once I removed the Racor filter
      that was mounted on the side of the engine compartment. The water muffler
      also had to be removed along with the coolant hoses that go to the hot
      water heater. oh, yeah, the two aft motor mounts also had to be removed.
      Then it slipped right out and up thru the companionway. The bottom of the
      tank had a small pin hole leak, with several bubbles in the paint??
      epoxy? that look like they were about to pop thru.

      I pulled the fuel pick up tube out. It is a piece of SS tubing about 6
      inches long. Attached to the tube is a rubber fuel hose (epoxied on) with a
      brass fitting on the end of the hose. The total length is 34 inches. Mind
      you, the tank is only 23 1/2 inches deep!! I would have thought it should
      have been like, 23 inches?
      The whole cradle that the tank rests on is infused with diesel.
      Actually, it’s seeping out of the wood. Some of the plywood strips on the
      bottom needs to replaced. They are3/4′ x 6″ wide x 34″ with some kind of
      beam stiffener attached to the bottom. Hard to tell what kind of wood it
      is, maybe teak or mahogany? Probably replace with plywood and oak, covered
      in West epoxy.
      I’ll have to a try and figure out how to clean up the diesel soaked
      wood that can’t be replaced – Ideas?

      As I had stated before, one of the reasons I chose this hull from the
      3 others I had looked at back in 2003, was that the tank was supposed to
      have been replaced in 2000. Looking at the sticker attached to the tank
      thru the gauge viewing port in the cockpit, you can see the sticker, and it
      looked like it was a “00”. Plus what the PO had stated. After I pulled the
      tank, it clearly says “80”. So I guess I got screwed.

      More coming soon
      Alan
      UNABATED #140
      _______________________________________________
      maillist mailing list

      https://pearson424.org/mailman/listinfo/maillist_pearson424.org

      —
      Bob Fine
      s/v Pelican
      Pearson 424 Hull #8
      http://thesailinglife.blogspot.com
      _______________________________________________
      maillist mailing list

      https://pearson424.org/mailman/listinfo/maillist_pearson424.org

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #81200
      Anonymous

      I figure it was so long, it had to be curled up and sucking all the crap right from the bottom of the tank.
      Alan

      Sent from my iPhone

      On Jul 2, 2014, at 7:46 AM, Robert Fine via maillist wrote:

      The pickup wasn’t original. The reason it was so long was so that it would
      pick up off the bottom of the tank so water wouldn’t sit there. The
      original was a stainless tube silver soldered to the tank top fitting
      straight down to within 1/2″ of the bottom.

      Bob

      On Wed, Jul 2, 2014 at 7:29 AM, Alan via maillist
      wrote:

      I finally got the fuel tank out last Friday. Pulled the tank out and
      loaded it in my truck by myself. Yikes…..
      The old tank slipped out pretty easy once I removed the Racor filter
      that was mounted on the side of the engine compartment. The water muffler
      also had to be removed along with the coolant hoses that go to the hot
      water heater. oh, yeah, the two aft motor mounts also had to be removed.
      Then it slipped right out and up thru the companionway. The bottom of the
      tank had a small pin hole leak, with several bubbles in the paint??
      epoxy? that look like they were about to pop thru.

      I pulled the fuel pick up tube out. It is a piece of SS tubing about 6
      inches long. Attached to the tube is a rubber fuel hose (epoxied on) with a
      brass fitting on the end of the hose. The total length is 34 inches. Mind
      you, the tank is only 23 1/2 inches deep!! I would have thought it should
      have been like, 23 inches?
      The whole cradle that the tank rests on is infused with diesel.
      Actually, it’s seeping out of the wood. Some of the plywood strips on the
      bottom needs to replaced. They are3/4′ x 6″ wide x 34″ with some kind of
      beam stiffener attached to the bottom. Hard to tell what kind of wood it
      is, maybe teak or mahogany? Probably replace with plywood and oak, covered
      in West epoxy.
      I’ll have to a try and figure out how to clean up the diesel soaked
      wood that can’t be replaced – Ideas?

      As I had stated before, one of the reasons I chose this hull from the
      3 others I had looked at back in 2003, was that the tank was supposed to
      have been replaced in 2000. Looking at the sticker attached to the tank
      thru the gauge viewing port in the cockpit, you can see the sticker, and it
      looked like it was a “00”. Plus what the PO had stated. After I pulled the
      tank, it clearly says “80”. So I guess I got screwed.

      More coming soon
      Alan
      UNABATED #140
      _______________________________________________
      maillist mailing list

      https://pearson424.org/mailman/listinfo/maillist_pearson424.org

      —
      Bob Fine
      s/v Pelican
      Pearson 424 Hull #8
      http://thesailinglife.blogspot.com
      _______________________________________________
      maillist mailing list

      https://pearson424.org/mailman/listinfo/maillist_pearson424.org

      _______________________________________________
      maillist mailing list

      https://pearson424.org/mailman/listinfo/maillist_pearson424.org

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #81201
      Anonymous

      That’s great Alan. Sounds like someone replaced that pick-up tube while the
      tank was still in place. Mine was a straight piece of copper tubing 23 1/2″
      long with a 45 degree cut at the bottom It was soldered into a SS fitting
      at the top of the tank. I replaced mine with an aluminum tube the same as
      the copper. The copper was showing signs of corrosion.

      The aft end of my crate (angled part) was a bit diesel soaked but still
      good. All the neoprene strips separating the tank from the wood were
      fastened with bronze staples. I removed all of them and replaced with
      aluminum tacks. The very bottom of the crate I completely removed the
      saturated plywood strips etc and replaced the whole bottom with one 2×6 PT
      plank sitting across wedge cut pieces that I epoxied and fastened in place
      to the hull. After the tank was back in place I replaced the forward end of
      the crate and through bolted it instead of screwing.

      If you take the time to clean up the outside of the tank as I did using an
      orbital sander with 100 grit, you might find as I did that only the bottom
      of the tank shows any damage. To save about $800 you can carefully cut the
      bottom of the tank off with a good jig saw and a metal blade, then clean
      and sand the insides as well to see if any corrosion has creeped up the
      sides of the tank. If not, all you need is to have a job shop weld a new
      piece on the bottom. Mine cost me $235 for the new bottom and the pick-up
      tube.

      Good luck,
      Ken

      On Wed, Jul 2, 2014 at 7:29 AM, Alan via maillist
      wrote:

      I finally got the fuel tank out last Friday. Pulled the tank out and
      loaded it in my truck by myself. Yikes…..
      The old tank slipped out pretty easy once I removed the Racor filter
      that was mounted on the side of the engine compartment. The water muffler
      also had to be removed along with the coolant hoses that go to the hot
      water heater. oh, yeah, the two aft motor mounts also had to be removed.
      Then it slipped right out and up thru the companionway. The bottom of the
      tank had a small pin hole leak, with several bubbles in the paint??
      epoxy? that look like they were about to pop thru.

      I pulled the fuel pick up tube out. It is a piece of SS tubing about 6
      inches long. Attached to the tube is a rubber fuel hose (epoxied on) with a
      brass fitting on the end of the hose. The total length is 34 inches. Mind
      you, the tank is only 23 1/2 inches deep!! I would have thought it should
      have been like, 23 inches?
      The whole cradle that the tank rests on is infused with diesel.
      Actually, it’s seeping out of the wood. Some of the plywood strips on the
      bottom needs to replaced. They are3/4′ x 6″ wide x 34″ with some kind of
      beam stiffener attached to the bottom. Hard to tell what kind of wood it
      is, maybe teak or mahogany? Probably replace with plywood and oak, covered
      in West epoxy.
      I’ll have to a try and figure out how to clean up the diesel soaked
      wood that can’t be replaced – Ideas?

      As I had stated before, one of the reasons I chose this hull from the
      3 others I had looked at back in 2003, was that the tank was supposed to
      have been replaced in 2000. Looking at the sticker attached to the tank
      thru the gauge viewing port in the cockpit, you can see the sticker, and it
      looked like it was a “00”. Plus what the PO had stated. After I pulled the
      tank, it clearly says “80”. So I guess I got screwed.

      More coming soon
      Alan
      UNABATED #140
      _______________________________________________
      maillist mailing list

      https://pearson424.org/mailman/listinfo/maillist_pearson424.org

      _______________________________________________
      maillist mailing list

      https://pearson424.org/mailman/listinfo/maillist_pearson424.org

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #81202
      Anonymous

      Already have a new tank being fabricated. with my luck if I had the bottom replaced, it would start leaking someplace else.
      As far as the neoprene strips are concerned, mine were stapled in but some out of place. according to an article on the web, the neoprene should be 5200ed to the tank so that there’s no airspace for possible crevice corrosion.
      Alan

      Sent from my iPhone

      On Jul 2, 2014, at 8:17 AM, Ken Page wrote:

      That’s great Alan. Sounds like someone replaced that pick-up tube while the tank was still in place. Mine was a straight piece of copper tubing 23 1/2″ long with a 45 degree cut at the bottom It was soldered into a SS fitting at the top of the tank. I replaced mine with an aluminum tube the same as the copper. The copper was showing signs of corrosion.

      The aft end of my crate (angled part) was a bit diesel soaked but still good. All the neoprene strips separating the tank from the wood were fastened with bronze staples. I removed all of them and replaced with aluminum tacks. The very bottom of the crate I completely removed the saturated plywood strips etc and replaced the whole bottom with one 2×6 PT plank sitting across wedge cut pieces that I epoxied and fastened in place to the hull. After the tank was back in place I replaced the forward end of the crate and through bolted it instead of screwing.

      If you take the time to clean up the outside of the tank as I did using an orbital sander with 100 grit, you might find as I did that only the bottom of the tank shows any damage. To save about $800 you can carefully cut the bottom of the tank off with a good jig saw and a metal blade, then clean and sand the insides as well to see if any corrosion has creeped up the sides of the tank. If not, all you need is to have a job shop weld a new piece on the bottom. Mine cost me $235 for the new bottom and the pick-up tube.

      Good luck,
      Ken

      On Wed, Jul 2, 2014 at 7:29 AM, Alan via maillist wrote:
      I finally got the fuel tank out last Friday. Pulled the tank out and loaded it in my truck by myself. Yikes…..
      The old tank slipped out pretty easy once I removed the Racor filter that was mounted on the side of the engine compartment. The water muffler also had to be removed along with the coolant hoses that go to the hot water heater. oh, yeah, the two aft motor mounts also had to be removed. Then it slipped right out and up thru the companionway. The bottom of the tank had a small pin hole leak, with several bubbles in the paint?? epoxy? that look like they were about to pop thru.

      I pulled the fuel pick up tube out. It is a piece of SS tubing about 6 inches long. Attached to the tube is a rubber fuel hose (epoxied on) with a brass fitting on the end of the hose. The total length is 34 inches. Mind you, the tank is only 23 1/2 inches deep!! I would have thought it should have been like, 23 inches?
      The whole cradle that the tank rests on is infused with diesel. Actually, it’s seeping out of the wood. Some of the plywood strips on the bottom needs to replaced. They are3/4′ x 6″ wide x 34″ with some kind of beam stiffener attached to the bottom. Hard to tell what kind of wood it is, maybe teak or mahogany? Probably replace with plywood and oak, covered in West epoxy.
      I’ll have to a try and figure out how to clean up the diesel soaked wood that can’t be replaced – Ideas?

      As I had stated before, one of the reasons I chose this hull from the 3 others I had looked at back in 2003, was that the tank was supposed to have been replaced in 2000. Looking at the sticker attached to the tank thru the gauge viewing port in the cockpit, you can see the sticker, and it looked like it was a “00”. Plus what the PO had stated. After I pulled the tank, it clearly says “80”. So I guess I got screwed.

      More coming soon
      Alan
      UNABATED #140
      _______________________________________________
      maillist mailing list

      https://pearson424.org/mailman/listinfo/maillist_pearson424.org

      _______________________________________________
      maillist mailing list

      https://pearson424.org/mailman/listinfo/maillist_pearson424.org

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #81203
      Anonymous

      Alan
      Assuming that Pearson made our boats about the same…

      – There was no paint or coating on my old tank.

      – The fuel pickup tube was solid all the way to the bottom of the tank.

      – The crate was all mahogany boards, no plywood. It was held together with bronze screws and staples.

      Looks like someone pulled your old tank and made a hasty repair at some point. I replaced my tank several years ago. It was a PIA to pull the damn thing out. I had to do much of what you listed below.

      As long as you have your tank out, consider putting in a remote fuel gauge. That inspection plate in the cockpit sole was stupid. You don’t have to mount the gauge on your instrument cluster. You could even put it below deck somewhere.

      When you replace the thing, keep the tank from contacting any metal fasteners.

      Good luck with your project.

      Rich


      Original Message


      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #81204
      Anonymous

      Yes, I had very slight signs of crevice corrosion where the neoprene came in contact with the aluminum so after replacing them with the tacks I also glued (polyurethane) additional strips to the tank. I had the room because my tank was a bit smaller after cutting and welding.
      Have fun,
      Ken

    • #81205
      Anonymous

      I was just outside looking at my old tank. upon further review I believe that this is the original tank. half-inch of the bottom was cut off and replaced. I say that because of the dimension of the bottom of the tank is 7 inches rather than 5 inches like two of the drawings I’ve seen online. plus the tank is a half inch shorter than the drawings I’ve seen. also the weld across the bottom does not look like the other factory welds. So it looks like I’ve got the original tank although a half inch shorter. the PO was right, he did replace the tank or rather he meant just the bottom of the tank.
      That explains the plywood in the cradle and the hose for the fuel pick up.
      Alan

      Sent from my iPhone

      On Jul 2, 2014, at 8:43 AM, Page Two via maillist wrote:

      Yes, I had very slight signs of crevice corrosion where the neoprene came in contact with the aluminum so after replacing them with the tacks I also glued (polyurethane) additional strips to the tank. I had the room because my tank was a bit smaller after cutting and welding.
      Have fun,
      Ken


      Ken and Vicky # 91……Writing a New Chapter Page by Page in an Old Book.

      _______________________________________________
      maillist mailing list

      https://pearson424.org/mailman/listinfo/maillist_pearson424.org

      _______________________________________________
      maillist mailing list

      https://pearson424.org/mailman/listinfo/maillist_pearson424.org

      Post generated from Pearson424 Forum using Mail2Forum

    • #81206
      quent
      Participant

      Alan
      Before you reinstall the tank, you might want to consider installing a high volume fuel cleaning system. These tanks are failing because water accumulates under the diesel, becomes acidic, and eats small holes in the bottom of the tank. Make the cleaning system pickup closer to the bottom than the engine pickup, then run it periodically and every time you fill up.
      Cleaning the fuel using the engine can be an expensive proposition.
      Quent

Viewing 8 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.